Well, I’m finally back from the Starry Heaven novel workshop. It was held in Flagstaff, AZ, and was largely organized by Sarah K. Castle, one of my Clarion classmates from way back in 2006. We had a great group of authors there. Sarah K. Castle, Greg van Eekhout, Sarah Prineas, Deb Coates, Debbie Daughtee, Rob Ziegler, Eugene Myers, Jon Hansen, Sandra McDonald (not MacDonald!), Bill Shunn, Gary Shockley, and, well, me! The basic criterion for inclusion was that you had to have sold at least one story to a professional market, though I think nearly everyone surpassed this by far. The format was stolen from the Blue Heaven workshop, and it roughly goes like this: Days 1, 2, and 3, the writers all critique one another’s first 50 pages. Everyone crits everyone else’s stuff. It’s a brutal, free-for-all bash fest, and many a time the evil incarnation of the nice authors who showed up on Welcome Night appeared and gave wicked reviews. That’s tough, to sit there and get reviews from people that have all earned their stripes. Days 4, 5, and 6 were less demanding. You had to critique two other novels, and two other writers had critique yours. Lots of work to get ready for these few days (reading and preparing comments for two novels), but once they arrived it was fairly smooth sailing. The sessions were alotted two hours, but they lasted more like and hour and a half.
For my part, I learned a lot. As with any workshop, you learn as much about writing from listening to others critique something that you’ve also read and critiqued as you do from people critiquing your own work. It’s always eye opening for me to hear what other people have to say about something I’ve tried really hard to find all the faults in. Invariably there are things that I missed, and it’s in those moments that you can grow as a writer if you internalize those thoughts.
Don’t get me wrong. I got a ton out of my first-50 crits and my novel crits as well. I have an issue with likeable protagonists. I try to paint them as people that need to grow. I show them with weaknesses early on so that the reader can see that they’re not perfect, that they have room to grow. That they’re regular people, basically. But the way I go about doing it is a bit off, I think. First impressions really count in fiction. It’s important to show them with heroic or admirable qualities early so that later, when they do see the bad stuff, they’re already predisposed to like them. The exact same person could be portrayed in an opening scene, but if the bad stuff comes first, then that’s what sticks with the reader. Not that my characterization was exactly on the money, either. I was a bit off the mark with Nikandr, the Prince and windship captain who the story is largely focused on. He came across as infantile, whiny, petty. I certainly wasn’t trying to portray him that way, but that’s certainly the way he came across. So I need to work on that. I think (hope) that those traits begin to fall away as the book progresses, and so the majority of the rework is going to come in the early parts of the novel. But I’m sure those changes will lead to other changes later on.
So I have my work cut out for me. I’ve got a long way to go and a short time to get there (at least by my self-assigned schedule), but I’m very hopeful that the end product is in sight now. I’m going to shoot for having Winds done by the time World Fantasy rolls around.
Entries (RSS)